Profile
Legal Structure
Mirpurkhas
Sugar Mill Limited (the Company) is a public listed Company and listed on
Pakistan Stock Exchange.
Background
The Company was incorporated on May 27, 1964 and
started its operations in 1965 with a crushing capacity of 1,500 TCD. Over the
years, through frequent BMR and capacity enhancements, crushing capacity has
been enhanced to 12,500 TCD. The Company's mill is located at Umerkot Road,
Mirpurkhas, Sindh. Meanwhile the head office is based in Karachi. The Company
also commenced corporate farming in 2012.
Operations
The Company’s operations are divided into two segments, i.e.
Sugar Segment, Paper and Board Segment. The sugar plant of the Company operated
for 97 days during MY24 (MY23: 87 days). Total
sugarcane crushed was 616,102MT during MY24 (MY23: 562,641MT). Whereas total
sugar produced was 66,101MT during MY24 (MY23: 59,325MT). Following this, the
recovery rate during MY24 stood at 10.73% (MY23: 10.55%). For Paper and Board
division, the Company has the production capacity of 250MT paper per day. It was also
told that the plant produced 31,968 tons of paper in 2023-24, compared to last
year, which was 17,959 tons.
The Company has also 33.33% ownership stake in Unicol Limited, a
joint venture between Faran Sugar Mills Limited and Mehran Sugar Mills Limited.
Unicol’s ownership is divided equally among the three stake holders.
Ownership
Ownership Structure
Major shareholding lies with the Faruque Group through
Faruque Pvt. Limited and its associated companies (49.28%), Sponsors of the
Company (0.87%), Banks, DFIs, NBFIs and others (9.37%), Insurance Companies (1.79%),
Modarabas (8.09%) and General Public (30.6%).
Stability
The
Group's long-term vision is supported by a multi-generational management
approach, with the third generation actively involved and the fourth generation
being strategically introduced at various business and operational levels. This is further reinforced by a well-defined
holding Company structure that fosters a shared understanding and clearly
defined interests among the family sponsors, ensuring sustained and stable
leadership.
Business Acumen
The Company is a part of Ghulam Faruque Group
and is one of its first ventures. The Group was founded by Mr. Ghulam Faruque
in 1964 through the establishment of Faruque (Private) Limited, the Parent
Company. Over the years, the Group has established a strong
foothold in various industries across Pakistan. After the demise of
Mr. Faruque, operations of group companies were taken over by his five sons,
who gradually expanded the business to where it stands today. The Group,
through its established entities, and various subsidiaries, holds a notable
position in the industries of cement, sugar, packaging, ethanol, software solution,
power, air conditioning and FMCG, among others.
Financial Strength
The Company derives financial strength from Ghulam Faruque
Group, which houses well-known entities, such as Cherat Cement Company Ltd.,
Cherat Packaging Ltd., Unicol Ltd., Unienergy Ltd. Faruque (Pvt.) Ltd., Greaves Pakistan (Pvt.) Ltd., Greaves Airconditioning (Pvt.) Ltd., Greaves Engineering Services (Pvt.) Ltd., Greaves CNG (PVT.) Ltd., and Zenosoft (Pvt.) Ltd. The Group's commitment to
contingency planning ensures the Company has access to necessary financial
support during times of financial challenge.
Governance
Board Structure
The
Company’s Board of Directors comprises seven members, including the Chairman,
three Non-Executive Directors including a female director, two Executive Directors and two Independent
Directors, one of whom is a representative of NIT.
Members’ Profile
Members of
the Company possess a diversified background. Mr. Arif Faruque is the chairman of
board and also CEO of Faruque (Pvt.) Limited. He is on the Board of
Directors of Cherat Packaging Ltd. and Cherat Cement Company Ltd. Besides the above, he is also a member
of the Board of Governors of Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS).
Board Effectiveness
The Board maintains effective oversight through
Board Audit Committee and HR & Remuneration Committee. High frequency of
Board of Directors & Committees' meetings bodes well for the Company.
Financial Transparency
Kreston Hyder Bhimji & Co. Chartered
Accountants, has expressed an unqualified opinion on the financial reports for
the Company for the year ending in Sept-24. The firm is classified under
category ‘A’ by the SBP and holds a satisfactory QCR rating.
Management
Organizational Structure
The Company functions through ten departments,
encompassing finance, sales, marketing, procurement, and internal audit, among
others. All department heads report to the COO, who concurrently serves as the
CFO. However, the heads of Internal Audit and HR report administratively to the
CEO and functionally to the Board Audit Committee and Board HR &
Remuneration Committee, respectively
Management Team
Management
comprises experienced individuals. The CEO, Mr. Aslam Faruque has experience
of above 4 decades. He also serves as the CEO of Unicol Ltd., a joint venture
distillery project. He is ably supported by COO & CFO - Mr. Wasif Khalid,
having an experience of above 2 decades.
Effectiveness
The Board maintains effective oversight through Board
Audit Committee and HR & Remuneration Committee. The frequent meetings of
the Board of Directors and its Committees are indicative of a proactive
approach, contributing positively to the Company's governance.
MIS
The
Company implemented SAP in 2010 and upgraded to SAP HANA in 2024. Production, sales and financial reports are submitted to
the senior management periodically.
Control Environment
In
order to ensure operational efficiency, the Company has setup an effective internal
audit function. The department conducts regular reviews to monitor
effectiveness of operations while identifying potential areas of improvements.
Business Risk
Industry Dynamics
Pakistan’s sugar industry stands as the second-largest Agro-based
sector in the country, comprising approximately 91 mills with an annual
crushing capacity of 80-90 million MT. Despite its scale, the industry faces
persistent challenges, particularly due to the Government-regulated sugarcane
support prices, which are set based on farmers’ costs and often constrain
millers' profitability. In MY24, sugar production was recorded at 6.76 million
MT. Despite that sugarcane production declined by 6.25% in MY24, due to
better weather conditions overall sugar production was slightly higher. Excess
sugar production over consumption and opening carryover stock of sugar, to manage the surplus inventory, the
Government permitted the export of 0.790 million MT of sugar, offering some
relief to the industry industry to reduce the impact of these setbacks, sugar production is estimated
to reduce by 10-15% due to non-availability of irrigation water across Pakistan , this will create a new equilibrium for sugar prices due to demand and
supply position against the national consumption of sugar.
Relative Position
The Company held ~0.9% share in total sugar
production of the country and holds a relatively low market share. Additionally, it is expanding its presence in the paper and board segment.
Revenues
The Company's MY24 financial performance presents a pronounced
dichotomy between revenue expansion and profitability. Despite a 54% topline
surge to PKR 12 billion, driven predominantly by sugar sales constituting 67%
of revenue, a substantial PKR 2 billion net loss was realized including loss of PKR 652 million shared by Unicol Limited, a stark contrast
to the prior year's PKR 839 million profit. This financial deterioration is
primarily attributable to a depressed sugar and paper sale prices coupled with significant escalation in sugarcane costs, OCC materials both import and local, impacting the cost of goods sold, and a concurrent surge in finance costs to
PKR 1.8 billion due to higher discounting rates, indicative of heightened debt servicing obligations.
Furthermore, paper division incurred a loss at the Profit Before
Interest and Taxes (PBIT) level due to elevated cost of sales, a consequence of
its developmental stage, effectively offsetting any potential profitability
from the core sugar segment and exacerbating the overall financial deficit.
Consequently, despite a marginal 0.9% market share in national sugar production
and substantial revenue growth, the Company's inability to translate these
gains into profitability underscores fundamental operational vulnerabilities.
Strategic imperatives necessitate effective management of escalating input
costs, rigorous financial restructuring to address burgeoning finance costs,
and targeted initiatives to enhance market share. Concurrently, a focused
approach to optimizing the paper division's cost structure and operational
efficiency is crucial to mitigate its negative impact and contribute to overall
financial stabilization and long-term sustainability.
Margins
The Company's MY24 financial performance demonstrates a
significant and concerning erosion of profitability across all key margin
metrics. Gross profit margins plummeted from 17.5% to 6.8%, directly reflecting
the substantial impact of rising sugarcane costs on the Company's core
operational efficiency. While operating profit margins appear to have decreased from 11.9% in MY23 to 2.0% in MY24, this apparent improvement is deceptive, as
it is largely negated by the substantial increase in finance costs and operating
expenses, which are factored in below the operating profit line. Critically,
net profit margins deteriorated dramatically, shifting from a positive 10.8% in
MY23 to a significant negative 18.6% in MY24. This drastic reversal underscores
the Company's vulnerability to escalating input costs, burgeoning finance
costs, and increased operating expenses, demanding immediate and comprehensive
strategic interventions to restore profitability and ensure long-term financial
stability.
Sustainability
High sugar price in the local market and robust
demand of ethanol in the export market during tends to bode well for the
Company, going forward. However, the Company is exposed to volatility and
ensuing challenges in the sugar sector. On the other hand, the Company has
successfully started commercial operations of its paper division from May 12,
2023 with the installed capacity of 250 tons' paper per day. To
reduce its paper business cost of goods manufactured, the company has announced
in December 24 to install a biomass pulping project with cost of Rs. 500
million, with a completion time of 16 months.
Financial Risk
Working capital
The
Company’s working capital management is largely a function of its inventory. An
inherent stress is faced by the Company due to seasonality in the crushing
cycle.
The Company's working capital dynamics in MY24 present a mixed picture. While
certain operational efficiencies were achieved, others experienced
deterioration. Specifically, inventory management demonstrated improvement,
with average inventory days reducing from 89 to 70 days, indicating enhanced
inventory turnover and potentially more efficient production or sales
processes. Conversely, trade receivable days lengthened from 18 to 32 days,
suggesting a potential increase in credit terms extended to customers or
challenges in collections, which could impact cash flow. Consequently, gross
working capital days decreased marginally from 108 to 102 days, reflecting the
combined effect of improved inventory days and worsened receivable days. Trade
payable days remained relatively stable, increasing slightly from 9 to 10 days.
Ultimately, net working capital days showed a modest improvement, decreasing
from 99 to 92 days. However, the significant deterioration in trade receivable
days warrants careful attention, as it could signal underlying issues with
credit management and potentially strain the Company's liquidity. While overall
working capital efficiency improved slightly, the lengthening receivable cycle
requires strategic review and potential corrective action to ensure sustainable
cash flow management.
Coverages
The Company's financial risk profile deteriorated significantly in MY24, as
evidenced by a substantial decline in key coverage ratios. Funds from Current
Financial Operations (FCFO) decreased sharply to PKR 494 million from PKR 1,057
million in MY23, while finance costs surged to PKR 1.8 billion from PKR 1.1
billion. Consequently, the FCFO to finance cost coverage ratio plummeted to
0.3x from 0.9x, indicating a diminished capacity to service debt obligations.
Furthermore, total coverage, reflecting the ability to cover all fixed charges,
also deteriorated markedly to 0.1x from 0.3x. This drastic reduction in
coverage ratios signals a heightened financial risk, reflecting the Company's
reduced ability to meet its financial commitments due to declining operating
cash flows and escalating finance costs, necessitating urgent financial
restructuring to mitigate potential liquidity and solvency issues.
Capitalization
The Company's capital structure exhibits a heightened level of financial leverage,
as evidenced by a substantial increase in the debt-to-equity ratio from 66% in
MY23 to 78% in MY24. This notable escalation is primarily attributed to a
significant expansion in the Company's borrowing activities, with total
borrowings rising from PKR 7,754 million to PKR 8,923 million. This increased
reliance on debt financing signifies a heightened financial risk profile,
potentially exposing the Company to increased interest rate sensitivity and a
greater vulnerability to financial distress in the event of adverse market
conditions or operational challenges. The elevated leverage necessitates a
strategic review of the Company's capital structure and a careful assessment of
its ability to service the increased debt load, emphasizing the need for robust
cash flow management and potential debt restructuring initiatives.
|