Profile
Legal Structure
Noon Sugar Mills was incorporated in 1964 as
a public limited Company, with its shares listed on the Pakistan Stock
Exchange (PSX). Primary business of the Company involves the manufacture and
sale of white refined sugar along with spirits.
Background
The
Company commenced commercial operations in 1966 with a daily crushing capacity
of 1,500MT of sugarcane per day. The Company upgraded its capacity twice since
conception. The first came in 2002, which brought crushing capacity to 4,000
TCD and the second was in 2007, increasing it to 10,000 TCD. The same levels
are maintained today. Additionally, the Company installed its distillery plant
in 1986 with the capacity to produce 50,000 liters per day. Since then, the Company has enhanced production capacity, which currently stands at 130,000
liters per day, accounting for the recent expansion of 50,000 liters made
during MY19.
Operations
Noon Sugar Mills has its registered office located on Sarwar Road,
Cantt, whereas, the mills are located in Sargodha. The Company has two
reportable segments, namely, sugar and distillery. Additionally, the Company
also operates a power plant with a rated capacity of 4MW. Power is used for
production and any surplus is sold to FESCO (Faisalabad Electric Supply
Company). During MY24, total cane crushed amounted to 712,164 metric
tons, compared to 807,367 metric tons in MY23. Sugar production for MY24 stood
at 73,597 metric tons, slightly lower than 75,717 metric tons in MY23. Sucrose
recovery improved to 10.30% in MY24, up from 9.37% in the previous year.
Additionally, ethanol production during MY24 totaled 13,429 metric tons,
compared to 18,334 metric tons in MY23.
Ownership
Ownership Structure
Majority of the shareholding lies with the Noon family, who
holds a 71% stake in the Company. The family holds ~36.33% directly through Ms.
Tahia Noon, 23.66% through Mr. Adnan and 11.25% through Mr. Taimur Hayat Noon. Whereas, ~5% is held
indirectly through Noon Industries limited, an associated Company. Remaining
shareholding is split between financial institutions and the general public.
Stability
The Company's ownership structure is expected to remain stable, with no major changes anticipated in the foreseeable future. As part of a long-term succession plan, the sponsors are actively involving the next generation in the business to ensure continuity and sustained growth.
Business Acumen
The
Company is a part of Noon Group which comprises a total of four companies.
With the exception of Noon Sugar Mills, other group companies are involved
trading services, with no significant asset base. The group previously used
to own and operate Noon Pakistan, most famous for its brand ‘nurpur’.
However, major shareholding of the Company was sold off to Fauji Foundation
Limited (FFL). The main sponsors now only holds an 11% stake in FFL, whereas,
Fauji Foods operates the brand ‘nurpur’
Financial Strength
With the exception of Noon Sugar Mills, majority
of the companies are involved in trading which provide indenting services
relating to the textile industry. Noon Sugar Mills is seen as the main Company
in the group since other companies do not generate sufficient revenues and have
an insignificant asset base.
Governance
Board Structure
The
Company’s Board of Directors consists of seven members, including, the
Chairman, two executive directors, two non-executive directors and two
independent directors.
Members’ Profile
Mr. K. Iqbal Talib, Chairman of the Board, has over 50 years of technical and management experience in the sugar industry. He was
previously the Chief Operating Officer and holds a Master’s degree in
Chemistry from Aligarh Muslim University. In addition to being the Chairman
of the Board, Mr. Talib was previously the President of Pakistan Society of
Sugar Technologists and Chairman of Pakistan Ethanol Manufactures
Association. Further, he is part of the Board in other group companies.
Board Effectiveness
The Company has three Board committees in place, namely, Human
Resources and Remuneration Committee, Technical Committee and Audit
Committee. All committees must comprise at least three members of the board.
Meetings are called when deemed fit, however, the Audit Committee must meet
at least once each quarter.
Financial Transparency
Noon Sugar Mills external auditors, Shinewing
Hameed Chaudri Company, Chartered Accountants, have expressed an unqualified
opinion on the Financial Statements of the Company ending in September, 2024.
The firm has been QCR rated by ICAP and are in Category 'B' of SBP panel
Management
Organizational Structure
Noon Sugar Mills has a well-defined
organizational structure that has various layers of management. All department
heads are reportable to General Manager Operations, who along with the Chief
Executive Officer, Manager Tax and Commercial Manager are Reportable to the
Chief Operating Officer. Subsequently, highest level of authority lies with the
Chief Executive.
Management Team
The management team of Noon Sugar Mills comprises seasoned professionals with diverse expertise across various domains. The Chief Executive Officer, Lt. Col. (R) Abdul Khaliq Khan, brings 25 years of military experience, encompassing operations, administration, human resource management, and strategic assessment. His leadership acumen has been further enhanced through participation in various executive seminars and professional development courses. Supporting him in key operational and financial functions are Mr. Syed Adeel Ahmed, Chief Operating Officer, and Mr. Rizwan Sohail, Chief Financial Officer, who contribute their extensive industry knowledge and expertise to the organization's strategic and operational decision-making processes.
Effectiveness
The absence of formal management committees within the Company indicates a gap in structured decision-making and internal governance mechanisms. This lack of dedicated committees for key operational areas may hinder the efficiency of strategic execution, risk management, and cross-functional coordination, potentially impacting overall management effectiveness. Implementing well-defined management committees could enhance accountability, streamline operational oversight, and improve strategic alignment with corporate objectives.
MIS
The management has implemented an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system, facilitating the integration of core business functions, including cane accounting, general ledger management, and human resource operations. This system enhances data centralization, process automation, and real-time reporting, thereby improving operational efficiency, financial control, and decision-making capabilities across the organization.
Control Environment
The Company has established an internal audit department to enhance financial oversight and compliance. All disbursements require prior approval from the internal audit function, ensuring robust internal controls. Departments are mandated to submit requisition forms, which must be reviewed and authorized by the internal audit department before processing. The Chief Financial Officer (CFO) and Chief Operating Officer (COO) jointly serve as the Company's authorized signatories, reinforcing financial governance.
Furthermore, the Company utilizes internally developed modules for monitoring operational performance. However, opportunities remain for further enhancement, as there is a need to strengthen and refine the existing control framework to optimize risk management and operational efficiency.
Business Risk
Industry Dynamics
Pakistan’s sugar industry stands as the second-largest
agro-based sector in the country, comprising approximately 91 mills with an
annual crushing capacity of 80-90 million MT. Despite its scale, the industry
faces persistent challenges, particularly due to the Government-regulated
sugarcane support prices, which are set based on farmers’ costs and often
constrain millers' profitability. In MY24, sugar production was recorded by,
6.7million MT, primarily due to the lower procurement of sugarcane resulting
from increased cost and reduced recovery rate. To manage the surplus inventory,
the Government permitted the export of 0.5 million MT of sugar, offering some
relief to the industry. Despite these setbacks, sugar production is estimated
to recover slightly to around 7 million MT. The Government’s continued support
for exports is expected to provide a much-needed boost to millers, helping them
navigate challenging industry dynamics and mitigate financial pressures.
Relative Position
Noon Sugar contributed ~ 1.1%
in the overall sugar production of the country making it one of the leading
sugar mills in Punjab region
Revenues
During MY24, revenue of the Company increased
and stood at PKR 11bln (M23: PKR 9bln) posted a growth of 22%. The Company
majorly derives its revenue from sugar (81%) and the ethanol segment (19%). During
MY24, the sugar segment’s revenue increased and stood at PKR 11bln (MY23: PKR
6bln). However, the sales of ethanol decreased and stood at PKR 2bln (MY23: PKR
4bln) due to a decrease in the global ethanol prices
Margins
The Company's financial
performance in MY24 exhibited a marked decline compared to MY23, primarily
driven by escalating sugarcane costs and heightened finance expenses. While
gross profit margins registered a reduction from 20% to 10% due to the
increased cost of raw materials, operational efficiency also suffered,
evidenced by a decrease in operating profit margins from 14% to 4.7%.
Critically, the compounding effect of these factors, coupled with a substantial
rise in finance costs, precipitated a shift from a 4.5% net profit margin in
MY23 to a net loss of 5.5% in MY24. This transition underscores the Company's
vulnerability to input cost volatility and the significant impact of elevated
finance charges on overall profitability, necessitating a strategic review of
cost management and financial leveraging to restore sustainable financial
performance.
Sustainability
The Company stands to benefit from the
combination of high sugar prices in the global market and strong demand for
ethanol in the export market. Nonetheless, the Company is vulnerable to
fluctuations and consequent difficulties in the sugar industry, such as low
prices for domestic sugar.
Financial Risk
Working capital
Noon
Sugar Mills faces an inherent stress in its working capital due to seasonality
in crushing cycle. The Company manages its working capital by taking advance
payments from their customers, which it uses during the crushing season to
purchase sugarcane stock. Any short fall is financed through short-term
borrowings, which make up a major portion part of the Company’s balance sheet. In
MY24, the Company's working capital cycle demonstrated a notable lengthening
compared to MY23. Inventory management efficiency declined, as evidenced by an
increase in average inventory days from 74 to 93, indicating slower inventory
turnover. While trade receivable days slightly extended from 10 to 13,
suggesting a marginal delay in collections, the overall gross working capital
days expanded significantly from 84 to 106. Concurrently, trade payable days
also increased from 40 to 46, reflecting a longer payment cycle to suppliers.
Consequently, net working capital days deteriorated from 44 to 60, signaling a
less efficient deployment of working capital and potentially impacting the Company's liquidity and operational flexibility.
Coverages
The Company's financial health deteriorated in MY24, as evidenced by a substantial
reduction in free cash flow from PKR 1.3 billion to PKR 588 million, coupled
with a significant surge in finance costs from PKR 703 million to PKR 1.8
billion. Consequently, the debt service coverage ratio plummeted from 1.9x in
MY23 to a concerning 0.5x in MY24, indicating a severely diminished capacity to
service debt obligations and raising serious concerns regarding the Company's
financial stability and future solvency.
Capitalization
Noon Sugar
Mills experienced a significant escalation in its financial leverage during
MY24, with the debt-to-equity ratio rising to approximately 79% from 47% in
MY23. This substantial increase in debt, primarily composed of short-term
borrowings constituting 95% of the total, was employed to address working
capital demands. The Company's total borrowings surged from PKR 1.8 billion in
MY23 to PKR 5.3 billion in MY24, indicating a notable intensification of
financial risk and heightened vulnerability to liquidity pressures, given the
preponderance of short-term debt obligations.
|